Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The fact that the number of valid positions is 19 x 19 in base 3 is wild. You'd have to be almost dan-level to immediately recognize that the pic above isn't actually a real game.


There are only 3^289 possible configurations of pieces on the board, so the fact that the number of legal configurations fits in a 289-digit ternary number is kind of trivial.


Yeah, I'm surprised more comments aren't pointing this out. To spell it out further:

> the number of valid positions [of a game on a 19 x 19 board] is 19 x 19 in base 3

This statement is true when replacing 19 with any number, since the number of legal and illegal configurations is exactly 3^(n*n).


There are four leading zeros, meaning that there are 19x19-4 (or 357) base three trits. Still remarkably close.


Not really. The T19 stone makes no damn sense, there's literally no reason to put a stone there. The T1 stone is an "empty triangle" AND in the corner, and only serves to weaken that position. The A1 / B1 stones are also worthless, and only serve to weaken white's position.

When I played seriously, I was only 14 Kyu (many years ago) and I immediately recognized that the board was not a real game. I'd imagine that any 10 to 20 Kyu player (very weak ranking, probably equivalent to D-rank players in Chess) would immediately recognize that the "game" in the picture was wrong.


It doesn't look like a real go game any more than randomly sprinkling chess figures on a chess board would :)


As someone who plays currently and is very far away from dan... this board is immediately random looking.


I would say no more than 10kyu (eg a14 a15)

The fact that it is 19x19 in base 3 is not that suprising. If you visualize all possible positons (legal or not) then you have 19x19 board of 3 states (black, white, note). So it's 3 * * (19 * 19). Which is 1 and 19 * 19 zeros in base 3. Only some of these positions are legal so the number is lower - quite a bit, that's why there are leading zeros in top left.


A1 and b1 too


The linked paper seemed really clear (I don't play Go, but I do study dynamic programming algorithms). So it may not pop out unless you play- but it looks like the black stones at Q2-R2 falsify the board (as they have no air holes). Actually I think the simplicity of the legality rule makes this even more interesting.


Q2 and R2 are part of a 9 stone black group that has 4 liberties




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: