Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No it does not. If you received no utility for your work but instead a 1:1000,000 chance of a million incomes, you would starve to death. The math you are using does not describe reality and rational people, since about Galileo anyway, have known better than to insist on broken models.

There is a reason people are willing to buy $1 lottery tickets but not $1000 tickets. (hint: a certainty of misery or high chance of death is not compensated by a remote chance of enormous wealth of ever decreasing marginal utility)

You are simply misunderstanding the use cost benefit, I assume because it clashes with some ideological point.

But if you want to buy a one in a million chance for a trillion dollars, I have a bitcoin address you could send a million bucks too.



The math you are using does not describe reality and rational people, since about Galileo anyway, have known better than to insist on broken models.

First of all, it's a textbook exercise in topology to show that any rational decision process must have a utility function (at least for a countably infinite set of choices).

Let me repeat the statement for utility functions. Suppose I have a 1% chance of being CEO and increasing my utility to U(CEO pay) - U(my pay). Suppose this increases to U(10x CEO pay) - U(my pay).

It's simple arithmetic that 0.01 x U(10X CEO pay) + 0.99 x U(my pay) > 0.01 x U(CEO pay) + 0.99 x U(my pay).

Rearranging the arithmetic, this is merely the statement that U(10X CEO pay) > U(CEO pay) - i.e. I'll be happier as a CEO with 10M than with 1M. Do you disagree with this statement?


You are using high school math incorrectly which is what results in the many obvious contractions I have listed above.

In the unlikely event you are actually interested in the correct formulation, you start to find the answer here [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_utility#Quantified_ma...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: