Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Changing the top idea in your mind is performing inception on yourself (hirehive.com)
43 points by nicholasjbs on Aug 20, 2010 | hide | past | favorite | 13 comments


On the subject if Inception...

I injured my shoulder playing football last week, with the result that lying down in bed can be quite uncomfortable. This means that I wake up quite a few times during the night, presumably as I toss and turn during light sleep phases. An interesting side effect of this is that I get to remember all dreams that I have during the night, not just the last one (usually the only one you remember cause it's the one you wake from).

Now, one surprise was how lucid some of these other dreams were. But more fascinating was that the content of the first dream was basically 'the top idea on my mind' from that day (and every day unfortunately, but that's another story). You see I hardly ever dream about the top idea on my mind, at least I didn't think I did. The dreams I remember are usually related to some minor point of the day. Otherwise it'd be great cause you could always choose what to dream about just by thinking about it a lot... well anyway my theory is that you dream about your top idea first and then forget about. By the time you get to your last nightly dream you're onto those minor issues at the end of the stack.

Also suggests that when people wake up with solutions to problems, it wasn't the subconscious, but rather something they consciously worked out in a dream they later forgot.

I don't think it'd be possible to perform Inception on yourself waking or dreaming, but perhaps one strategy would be identifying what really IS the top idea. You may think it's money matters, leaving you helpless to free your mind until resolution arrives (which could be out of your control), but maybe it's really something else like you haven't planned what to do once the matter is settled. Take your thoughts as far as they'll go, follow up every avenue of inquiry to a reasonable end, and then they'll leave you alone.


Also key to the likelihood of an idea capturing your mind is how it emotionally engages you.

In fact, I could go farther, stating that ideas alone can't be in the tops of our minds, but rather, some idea-emotion hybrid.

"Top intuition" is the closest phrase I can think of.


Good point. Since I read Graham's article I've found myself often saying, "I don't want this at the top of my mind." The things that sneak up there are usually strongly emotion-based.

Clarifying and writing things down is also a way to clear them from your mind. S, the mnemonicist Luria described, had trouble forgetting so he would write things down so he could discard them.


This is a good point. It made me realize a third time when my mind tends to wander to its top idea/intuition: when I'm walking around listening to music. It's a bit like day-dreaming, and I'd argue that the fact it's triggered by music is indicative that there is strong emotional piece here.


Seems like pg's essay performed an inception on this guy already. :-)


Ha, yeah. I realized that right when I finished. Somehow I don't think I'm the only one, either.


From the article:

> the number of words it takes to state a thought is directly proportional to how clearly you understand it

This agrees with my experience, and is a powerful thing to recognise.


>> directly proportional

Inversely.


There are so many other factors involved that the number of words barely means anything.

Culture, audience, complexity... These things all dwarf understanding when it comes to expressing an idea.


I agree, but I don't think that negates the point.


Perhaps minimal number of words was implied.


Incepbation

(the article, and my opinion of it, in one word)


I really hope "inception" doesn't become a thing...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: