Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What do you find ugly about them? I actually prefer them to google maps! Also, the naming of the streets is often clearer (in google maps, there are too many streets without name, even if you zoom on them). The overall user interface, however, is often much clearer in the google app.


There's no hierarchy in the coloring. Everything is big and bold and it takes more effort to find the parts I care about.

The POI icons are huge. The text for obvious things ("New York City" when I'm staring at just Manhattan) is huge and unnecessary. There are too many shown at the street level. Every block has restaurants and bus stops. They're not labeled, just taking up a huge amount of space.

It feels like an old linux desktop, before they got usable.

The map is covered in visual clutter that takes too much effort to visually process.

I agree that Google Maps needs more street names, but that's my only complaint about the map. That's an easy fix.


It looks like a satnav from the early '00s... No subtlety in the colors at all.

Mapbox Streets is an example of good map design: https://www.mapbox.com/maps/streets/


Mapbox is built on OSM data and has pretty nice styling. Gaia GPS is one app that provides (among many other things) Mapbox layers on iOS and Android.


Hehe, I had just edited my comment to mention Mapbox, then I noticed your reply. :)


> Mapbox Streets is an example of good map design: https://www.mapbox.com/maps/streets/

Hmm, doesn't show forests and doesn't show built-up areas, either, which are precisely the things I really dislike about Google's map design, too.


Looks like a cheap old satnav!


I like this aesthetics. The google colors for maps look sad and bland to me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: