Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because watching television or going to a football match is clearly entertainment.

But you get a discount on electric installation if you sign up for your new service online.

Internet service isn't just entertainment: It is communication, banking, and lots of very basic things folks need in life. It just happens to be multi-purpose, so you get the entertainment value as well.

Many jobs require internet access to apply: Fewer and fewer take any sort of paper applications and not everywhere has kiosks to apply and test at (low paying jobs, at least). Heck, game disks are getting rarer, so you sometimes need to be online to use a PC game. Lots of research for school papers is done online.

Also, communication. Few folks send snail mail letters anymore due to email. Chat programs work well too.

If you aren't connected to the internet, you are at a disadvantage. I cannot say that about television in general or a football match - going without those sometimes means you don't have as much to talk about with folks that consume those.



Even without home internet, cell phones with data plans are cheap and ubiquitous. Even most “poor” people have at least a cheap Android phone with a prepay plan with data.


Curious if this was also true in the old days with telephony.


>But you get a discount on electric installation if you sign up for your new service online.

That should be illegal. It's discrimination for a basic service.

>Internet service isn't just entertainment: It is communication, banking, and lots of very basic things folks need in life.

You can still walk into the bank. Checking your account from home is cool, but hardly a vital thing.

>Many jobs require internet access to apply: Fewer and fewer take any sort of paper applications and not everywhere has kiosks to apply and test at (low paying jobs, at least). Heck, game disks are getting rarer, so you sometimes need to be online to use a PC game. Lots of research for school papers is done online.

I doubt they can pull this shit off in a place where 25% of people have no access to the Internet. Otherwise they wouldn't find applicants.

>Also, communication. Few folks send snail mail letters anymore due to email. Chat programs work well too.

A bummer. Hardly a "human rights" issue.


> You can still walk into the bank. Checking your account from home is cool, but hardly a vital thing.

What are you talking about? A lot of Alabama (and the US generally) is unbanked specifically because there's no bank in walking distance.


> That should be illegal. It's discrimination for a basic service.

There are all kinds of things where there's a service fee tacked on for more expensive or convenient ways of accessing city or public services. I can apply for parking permit or pay parking tickets for free if I walk to the parking office, or for the cost of a stamp, envelope, and a check if I mail it, or for a 2.75% (minimum $1.50) convenience charge if I use a credit card.

Am I being discriminated against without even realizing it?


That should be illegal. It's discrimination for a basic service.

So instead of giving a discount for signing up online, they should charge everyone the same price which would be the non discounted price - how does that help?


What if they don’t want a job in their area (ie want to move away?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: