Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Every phrase was fascinating and revealing:

1. "I'm not an expert on traditional finance"

Clearly.

2. "it's a lot more boring"

So I knew this guy who used to game the customs at New Delhi airport. Back in the day he would fly over to Singapore, buy some expensive electronics, and try to get it past customs without paying duty - he was a "mule."

There was one particular customs agent who knew this guy and would catch him. The mule would pick flights during that agent's shift - told me that it was boring otherwise.

These kids were getting a kick out of risky trades.

3. "conservative enough that it's very unlikely for you to actually lose all your money."

This tells me they knew what they were up to and they didn't really care - it was part of the game.

The whole saga is fascinating. Can't wait for the book/movie combo to come out.



>1. "I'm not an expert on traditional finance"

>Clearly.

And is that a problem? "traditional finance" is a sprawling subject. There are literally four year degrees on "finance". Yet, jane street hires (a "traditional finance" trading firm) regularly hires people with only mathematics degrees to trade for them. Other hedge funds/trading firms do the same as well.

> 2. "it's a lot more boring"

>There was one particular customs agent who knew this guy and would catch him. The mule would pick flights during that agent's shift - told me that it was boring otherwise.

>These kids were getting a kick out of risky trades.

Don't you think you're reading a little too much into this? Someone calls traditional finance boring so they must be some sort of adrenaline junkie?

>3. "conservative enough that it's very unlikely for you to actually lose all your money."

>This tells me they knew what they were up to and they didn't really care - it was part of the game.

In some ways traditional finance's margin requirements are more conservative. Regulation T specifies that for stocks, initial margin is 50% (ie. if you buy $100 worth of stocks, you need to pay for $50 out of your own pocket), and maintenance margin is 25%. A quick search says that FTX's margins are 10% and 5% respectively. However, in other ways traditional finance's margin requirements are looser. Because they expect that the lender is a legal entity they can go after, they're much more lenient when it comes to liquidating customer's accounts. That's how lenders got burned on Archegos, because Archegos were giving excuses, the lenders believed them (also, liquidating your customer is rude and they don't want to lose their business), and didn't liquidate them. Crypto on the other hand is far more conservative in this regard, because they basically assume that the only assets you have are the assets in your account. To that end, crypto exchanges (including FTX) have margin monitoring 24/7 and will automatically liquidate customer accounts when they dip too low. So to get back to your original point, they do care, and it's something they thought long and hard about.


FTX and crypto were background noise for me. Clearly you appear to know more about these things than I do.

I look forward to seeing how this plays out, especially for Lewis' book.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: