Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not to distract, as these are all valid concerns, but why on earth is anyone leaving anything on an exchange for longer than it takes for the deposit, transaction, and withdrawal to clear.


To save on transaction fees perhaps, or to because they don't want to run the risk of looking after their own keys.


> why on earth is anyone leaving anything on an exchange for longer than it takes for the deposit, transaction, and withdrawal to clear.

I've never advised my dad to take his crypto off of Coinbase, and he's been keeping it there safely for about six years at this point. It's the best place for him to keep it, for better or worse. I'm not there to transfer everything to a ledger as he trades, and I also don't really want to take responsibility for all of his funds anyway. If he started trading on Binance US (not gonna happen) then I would probably just tell him to send it to Coinbase. I don't keep my crypto on exchanges, but for a lot of people, it really is better than the alternatives.


Because they are day-trading, and if everyone stopped day-trading, all of these exchanges would collapse overnight. They can't sustain themselves off people buying coins once a year.


Because they might have to pay taxes on it.


possibly so they can engage in other transactions with other users of the same platform without waiting for half an hour

(lightning or ethereum would also solve this problem, but binance has more users despite being a company instead of a protocol)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: