Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>> Autopilots are very good and they are servoing to the pressure altitude.

It would have been cool to use a phone to record a GPS track with altitude and compare them. Pressure != GPS. Also wonder if there would be distinct jumps in the difference if they reset the pressure based altimeter to a different AWOS.

Not sure how it works in big planes, but in little ones you need to set your altimeter based on the local weather. The weather stations measure barometric pressure at their elevation and "correct it to sea level" you get this corrected reading over the radio and set it in your altimeter so your pressure-based altitude reading is corrected for local weather variations. Just going out flying for an hour the altimeter setting when returning to the same place might be off by a few millibar.



The QHN/Kollsman window setting only affects what is displayed to the wetware. When you strip away all that the autopilot is just servoing to a pressure altitude. But sure if you are flying below the transition altitude and are flying between areas with different QNH settings when you adjust the setting the autopilot will climb or descend as needed because you told it to servo to a different pressure altitude.

There are many EFB (e.g. Foreflight), or log book, or other flight recorders you can use on an iPhone. And some can record the pressure transducer in the iPhone to record an approximate "pressure altitude". e.g. Naviter SeeYou Navigator intended for gliders can do that (but it's not unusual for modern gliders to have an array of sophisticated air data sensors and specialized variometers and flight computers that would feed the app this data over Bluetooth). Popular EFB software Foreflight will not use the iPhone pressure transducer, if you want pressure data there you need to drive that through an external interface like a Sentry ADS-B receiver that has a pressure sensor built into it -- or much better if the aircraft is equipped with ADS-B Out can receive the "own-ship" ADS-B Out broadcast pressure altitude from it's high accuracy encoder). Any in-cabin pressure traducer will be sensitive to the difference between calibrated static pressure and cockpit pressure, things like opening or closing vents, or varying the airspeed significant (and ram air pressure or suction on the cockpit exit vents) can cause observable changes. And when using an iPhone or similar, especially without a great GPS satellite overhead view (e.g. in high wing aircraft) you are likely not to get high-quality GPS altitude data. think best case ~ +/- hundred feet, worse case with little overhead GPS sat view, much worse... but those consumer GPS app is likely to happily display multiple decimal points of precision :-)


You use standard pressure (29.92 inHg) above transition altitude, which, in the United States, is 18,000 feet. Pilots wouldn't be changing the altimeter after climbing past this point, and would start using local values once descending through it again.

Of course, your initial point is still correct: there could be slight variations if using those local settings and getting different values, but you'd only see that below transition altitude.


At high altitude you do this stuff "When you set your altimeter to 29.92, you're flying at standard pressure altitude."

The idea is all the planes use the same setting so the one at FL35 doesn't hit the one at FL36. But those are not exactly 35000 and 36000 feet above sea level.


nitpicking: that would be FL350 and FL360




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: