Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

my saddest story there is "frank'n stein" a hilarious comedy movie and theatre play toying with the Frankenstein plot.

I've seen the movie and it made ma watch a local play and I loved both.

when I tried to get hold of the DVD years later I learned that the heirs to the author Ken Campbell had withdrawn all rights. this removed all prints from all libraries too. the thing is _gone_. because the heirs hated their gene provider so much.

I was amazed this is possible... "freedom of speech"? nope. intellectual property.



That seems... wrong?

You can't unpublish a book by withdrawing the right and force the destruction of already sold copies. I believe DVDs fall under the same first sale doctrine, so this story seems to be missing some details.


it's not a normal book, it's a theatre play, a script. and the license owner can restrict the rights for these to be useless unless relicensed. it was mind bending to me. and yes, it feels wrong.


Yes a play can no longer be performed, but a recording of a play is a different thing.

A songwriter can stop anyone from making new covers of their song, but they can't order the destruction of your CDs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: