Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How can a commercial solution prevent backdoors?

A sensitive product like this would have to defend against well funded, patient, well resourced threats, including but not limited to infiltrating an organzation in order to plant code that only a few people may even be able to notice.



Well for one they need to show up in person. They can't be some anon anime character who hides their identity for totally legitimate reasons.


As an employee, I've typically needed to show up in person, but I've worked with contractors who never showed up in person. I've even been such a contractor at times.

Lots of commercial products use contractors and licensed code in the final product.

At least with most open source projects, a lot of the contribution process is in the open, so you could watch it you wanted to. As DonHopkins writes elsewhere, few people do, but it's possible. Not a lot of commercial projects offer that level of transparency into changes.


It's extremely easy for a three-letter agency or similar to plant a new employee.

Corporate espionage may not be talked about very much, but it is still very fashionable. Even without state sponsored attackers.


I worked at my current job for 3 months before I met a coworker in person. That might slightly help at a legacy butts-in-seats factory, but doesn't do a lot for remote jobs. I could be proxying in from Romania for all they'd know.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: