Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Although I agree with the general sentiment, but I'll slightly push back on the "nobility" of any engineering pursuit. Such things are highly amoral (not immoral) and context specific

Assume an "Evil" state worked on defensive technology that can foil any nuclear attacks against it. Now, this allows this "Evil" state to use it's own nuclear weapons without fear of retaliation. So in this example the innovation made in defensive technologies allowed for war and destruction



Well of course, which is why we prohibited the development of defence tech in the ABM treaty. But that doesn't stop non-nuclear states from developing anti-nuke defence technology. Perhaps the only reason why they don't is because it's harder than building a nuke.


It is incredible naïveté to associate technology as good and bad.

Which one is the Internet


Exactly, that's why I objected to the "noble" aspect of working on defensive technologies




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: