Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How exactly is money laundering not unethical? What's so ethical about assisting someone in getting away with a crime?


Just because something is illegal doesn't mean it is wrong. There are a lot of sociopath control freaks that want to dictate morality to the world, or to have power and control over others. There are many "crimes" that one might participate in that are perfectly valid business transactions such as consumption of controlled substances and prostitution. Right and wrong transcend words written on paper. One might argue that enabling the freedom to participate in these markets safely is extremely ethical and those attempting to restrict these markets are the criminals.


I think you need to explain why money laundering is unethical. Because there are plenty of laws passed by various governments that many people feel would be unethical to follow.

To use an extreme example, was it unethical to hide jews from the Nazi's?


Always replace Hitler with Stalin or Mao or you'll be swamped by the idiots quoting Godwin's Law.


Money laundering happens to avoid paying taxes

hiding Jews from the Nazis was to avoid them getting shipped off to death camps.

The question is thus do you think that taxes are unethical? I don't think so but a lot of bitcoin fans seem to think so.


It can be more complex than that. An extreme pacifist could have no problem with taxes per se but feel that paying taxes today implicates him in war crimes (drones strikes, etc.)


Godwin's Law much?


This conversation is officially over http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law


Fuck off. So he used an extreme example, doesn't mean his point is invalid. Godwin's Law is not supposed to be used as an excuse to shut down uncomfortable conversations.


Godwin's law makes the money laundering law attractive in comparison.


Who says that everyone who wants privacy necessarily wants it for criminal purposes?


I'm guessing the intent is to say that anonymizing the source of money per se doesn't seem to do anyone any harm, much like accepting cash as a form of payment. The problem is when people use such channels to avoid detection of crimes by law enforcement. We have to decide as a society which conveniences or defenses of privacy (anonymizing the source of money being one) are worth sacrificing to enable better law enforcement.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: