Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is no quote that "the smarter you are, the more false assumptions you have". I can't even find the words false or assumption in the article. You are strawmanning or reading incorrectly.

This is what he says:

  > Here's the problem. Logic is a pretty powerful
  > tool, but it only works if you give it good input.
  > As the famous computer science maxim says, 
  > "garbage in, garbage out." If you know all the
  > constraints and weights - with perfect precision
  > - then you can use logic to find the perfect 
  > answer. But when you don't, which is always, 
  > there's a pretty good chance your logic will lead
  > you very, very far astray.
My personal experience in life has been that this is the case. No matter how much I have studied, it's not possible to logic your way out of insufficient or misperceived data which in most domains other than programming is the rule.

I've also experienced the same over-confidence of logical thinkers kept in bubbles - they adjust to the quantity and correctness of data they have in one part of their life and then use logic and cognitive biases to rationalise the outcomes they have in life.



> My personal experience in life has been that this is the case. No matter how much I have studied, it's not possible to logic your way out of insufficient or misperceived data which in most domains other than programming is the rule.

> I've also experienced the same over-confidence of logical thinkers kept in bubbles - they adjust to the quantity and correctness of data they have in one part of their life and then use logic and cognitive biases to rationalise the outcomes they have in life.

Well if they use logic then they are dumb, not smart. Centuries ago we've invented better tools called statistics and probability theory that are designed to deal with uncertain and incorrect data, and do this job optimally, as opposed to human intuition and cognitive shortcuts humans normally do.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: